BPMS Watch: Process Model Portability: Does Anyone Care?

Author(s)

Business Relationship Manager - Product Lifecycle Management, Chevron Corporation

Among the numerous virtues of BPMN, foremost is vendor independence, giving process modelers many tools to choose from, all describing processes using the same shapes and semantics. That’s huge, since without low-cost (or even free) tools you’ll never establish a culture of process broadly throughout the business. Occasionally, however, a student in my BPMN training will ask the embarrassing question, “So that means I can take the models I create in this class and import them into the BPMN tool we use in our company… Right?” Uh… well, not necessarily.

It seems that the number one reason for creating a standard in the first place – portability and interoperability across tools – was somehow forgotten by the BPMN standards committee in OMG. And a good solution is not yet clearly in sight.

First of all, lest anyone doubt that BPMN has become the de facto standard for process modeling – at least where BPMS-based implementation is contemplated – then consider that Appian, Lombardi, Savvion, Tibco, Intalio, SoftwareAG, and Oracle all use it today, and IBM, SAP, and BEA are planning to move to it soon. If BPMN is not on the analysts’ BPM RFP checklist today, it certainly will be next year. That’s what makes it so unbelievable that we still lack a standard XML interchange format for BPMN models.

There are three potential solutions on the table. All of them have problems, some fundamental, some fixable. But fixing the problems requires pressure from the BPM user community, pressure that so far has been absent. Tool vendors, it seems, like to import from standard formats, but export… not so much.

Solution #1 is to use BPEL as the model interchange format. BPEL is an OASIS standard for executable processes modeled as orchestrations of web services. Among the BPMN vendors, Oracle is perhaps the leading proponent of this approach.  BPEL has in its favor the fact that it can handle BPMN’s event and transaction compensation behavior, and is a well-defined standard designed for portability … at least for the parts of the process described by BPEL. The problem, however, is that BPEL 2.0 does not describe human tasks, subprocesses, and other central features of BPMN process models. Also, BPMN’s freeform activity flows do not always map easily to BPEL’s “block-oriented” structure. But one can at least envision how BPEL, enhanced with People and Subprocess extensions, could be used for BPMN interchange, or at least a subset that excludes a few unmappable routing topologies.

Solution #2.is to use XPDL from the Workflow Management Coalition.  XPDL was originally created to allow interchange between process modeling and workflow automation tools. Developed in a pre-SOA era, XPEL 1.0 lacked the necessary event-handling features, but version 2.0 was extended to include all of the elements described by BPMN. A lingering problem with XPDL is that it focuses on interchange of the diagrams but not necessarily the underlying process models. Not only does XPDL not demand that “compliant” tools support any particular subset of BPMN semantics, but it does not even insist that all tools serialize the same diagram in the same way. I have urged them to make model portability a priority in the upcoming XPDL 2.1, and I believe they will. I think users want to port the models, not just the pictures.  But I believe WfMC is sensing a new opportunity here. Given that most BPMSs today are not BPEL-based, XPDL 2.1 has a much better chance of becoming the accepted interchange standard for BPMN.

Solution #3 is OMG’s own Business Process Definition Metamodel, or BPDM.  BPDM has the singular advantage of being the officially sanctioned BPMN interchange standard from the organization that owns BPMN. However, it suffers from some serious problems of its own, not the least of which being that its developers believe they need to “fix” BPMN before they can serialize it, since (they say) the semantics are not precise enough.  Precise enough for what? After hours of discussion with these guys, it turns out that they mean precise enough for identical runtime behavior or for exact mapping to UML. For me, that’s when the alarm bells go off, since if you believe that the implementer’s view of a BPMN process is really UML or Java, you’re out of touch with today’s BPM. In any case, the ability to create a BPMN model in tool A and then edit it in tool B is not the same goal as generating unique UML or Java code from a particular BPMN diagram. The former is a real need of process modelers today, as imperfect as BPMN 1.0 is. But OMG’s goal with BPDM appears to be the latter. Whatever merits it may have as a formal metamodel, I just can’t see BPDM succeeding as an interchange format for BPMN process models in the near term.

Each of these “solutions” to BPMN model portability, you may have noticed, is actually a by-product of some other goal of the standards committee, which explains why none hit the mark. But is model portability even an important goal? If so, practitioners need to make that need felt by the standards bodies, the analysts, or someone. And what does portability even mean? Do you need to preserve the exact look of the diagram? Do you need to preserve the same runtime behavior? Is BPMN even about specifying precise runtime behavior? Unfortunately, there is no consensus on these questions.

Similar Resources

Enhancing Your Team’s BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise

Enhancing Your Team’s BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Enhancing Your Team's BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise In today’s dynamic business environment, managing and improving business processes is critical for any organization aiming to maintain a competitive edge. Many companies consider handling Business...

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+ Introduction In the evolving landscape of Business Process Management (BPM), the introduction of Shared Data Model Notation (SDMN) marks a significant advancement. As businesses increasingly seek to...

Embracing the Future: Low-Code and No-Code Platforms in BPM+

Embracing the Future: Low-Code and No-Code Platforms in BPM+

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Embracing the Future: Low-Code and No-Code Platforms in BPM+ Introduction In the realm of business process management (BPM), low-code and no-code platforms have emerged as transformative tools, reshaping how organizations develop applications and manage workflows....

Featured Certificate: BPM Specialist

Everyone starts here.

You're looking for a way to improve your process improvement skills, but you're not sure where to start.

Earning your Business Process Management Specialist (BPMS) Certificate will give you the competitive advantage you need in today's world. Our courses help you deliver faster and makes projects easier.

Your skills will include building hierarchical process models, using tools to analyze and assess process performance, defining critical process metrics, using best practice principles to redesign processes, developing process improvement project plans, building a center of excellence, and establishing process governance.

The BPMS Certificate is the perfect way to show employers that you are serious about business process management. With in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management, you'll be able to take your business career to the next level.

Learn more about the BPM Specialist Certificate

Courses

  •  

 

Certificates

  • Business Process Management Specialist
  • Earning your Business Process Management Specialist (BPMS) Certificate will provide you with a distinct competitive advantage in today’s rapidly evolving business landscape. With in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management, you’ll be able to take your business career to the next level.
  • BPM Professional Certificate
    Business Process Management Professional
  • Earning your Business Process Management Professional (BPMP) Certificate will elevate your expertise and professional standing in the field of business process management. Our BPMP Certificate is a tangible symbol of your achievement, demonstrating your in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management.

Certification

BPM Certification

  • Make the most of your hard-earned skills. Earn the respect of your peers and superiors with Business Process Management Certification from the industry's top BPM educational organization.

Courses

 

Certificates

  • Operational Excellence Specialist
  • Earning your Operational Excellence Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in driving organizational excellence and achieving sustainable improvements in performance.
 

 

OpEx Professional Certificate

  • Operational Excellence Professional
  • Earn your Operational Excellence Professional Certificate and gain a competitive edge in driving organizational excellence and achieving sustainable improvements in performance.

Courses

Certificate
  •  

  • Agile BPM Specialist
  • Earn your Agile BPM Specialist Certificate and gain a competitive edge in driving business process management (BPM) with agile methodologies. You’ll gain a strong understanding of how to apply agile principles and concepts to business process management initiatives.  
 

Business Architecture

 

Certificates

  • Business Architecture Specialist
  • The Business Architecture Specialist (BAIS) Certificate is proof that you’ve begun your business architecture journey by committing to the industry’s most meaningful and credible business architecture training program.

  • Business Architecture Professional
  • When you earn your Business Architecture Professional (BAIP) Certificate, you will be able to design and implement a governance structure for your organization, develop and optimize business processes, and manage business information effectively.

BA CertificationCertification

  • Make the most of your hard-earned skills. Earn the respect of your peers and superiors with Business Architecture Certification from the industry's top BPM educational organization.

Courses

 

Certificates

  • Digital Transformation Specialist
  • Earning your Digital Transformation Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in today’s rapidly evolving business landscape. 
 

 

  • Digital Transformation Professional
  • The Digital Transformation Professional Certificate is the first program in the industry to cover all the key pillars of Digital Transformation holistically with practical recommendations and exercises.

Courses

Certificate

  • Agile Business Analysis Specialist
  • Earning your Agile Business Analysis Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in the world of agile software development.

Courses

Certificate
  • DAS Certificate
  • Decision Automation Specialist
  • Earning your Decision Automation Certificate will empower you to excel in the dynamic field of automated decision-making, where data-driven insights are pivotal to driving business innovation and efficiency.