BPMS Watch: The DI Mess

Author(s)

Business Relationship Manager - Product Lifecycle Management, Chevron Corporation

BPMS Watch readers know I am a big fan of OMG’s Business Process Modeling Notation (BPMN) 2.0, which has passed its first approval hurdle and is now in the Finalization Task Force stage. A major reason is that for the first time, BPMN has standardized the schema for XML interchange of process models. That means you will be able to create a BPMN model in one tool with confidence you can open it in a different tool.  I think that’s what every user expects from a “standard,” but BPMN never had it until v2.0.  But there is one part of the standard that the team messed up big time: Diagram Interchange (DI), meaning the graphical layout of the shapes and symbols. Prior to BPMN 2.0, the de facto interchange format for BPMN models has been XPDL, an existing standard from the Workflow Management Coalition (WfMC) modified to handle BPMN. Each node in XPDL represents both an element in the BPMN semantic model and its corresponding visual element – including position, size, and other graphical details – in the diagram. But BPMN 2.0 separates the semantic model from its diagrammatic representation. That’s in a separate model – the DI model – that sits alongside the semantic model in the XML interchange document.  That’s actually a good thing. It allows multiple diagrams (views, pages, etc.) to represent the same semantic element in different ways, such as different levels of detail. For example, if you have a hierarchical diagram of a complex process model, with a top-level view showing the entire process at very coarse-grained detail and many child-level views showing increasing levels of detail, BPMN 2.0 maintains a single consistent semantic model for the process, referenced by all the various views. That is good for maintaining the integrity of the model. In contrast, with XPDL each view of a particular model element represents a different XML element in the export, so if a subprocess or pool appears on multiple pages of the model, it is up to the tool – or the modeler – to maintain consistency between their definitions.

But OMG did not want to make DI, the graphical model, BPMN-specific. They wanted it to support other types of diagrams as well, particularly UML, something completely different but also owned by OMG. And they didn’t want to define the format in an XML schema document (XSD), the universal standard used by XML tools, SOA, and BPM. They wanted to define it in XMI (XML Model Interchange), OMG’s own standard for interchanging UML models. The problem with DI as specified in the BPMN 2.0 draft is that BPMN-specific diagram structure is not defined in a format usable by XML tools.  Instead, it is defined in a separate “library,” which you could think of as a cheat sheet off to the side to remind you of the particular attributes allowed or required for BPMN-specific shapes.

If you think that is a strange way to define what is still nominally a notation (i.e. graphics) standard, you are not alone.

The problem is not that it is impossible to define a BPMN 2.0 model using the graphics as specified by DI, just that it will be too difficult to do so in practice. Unless you can represent DI as a true BPMN-specific schema, tool implementers cannot use the rich array of XML tools available to validate, transform, and test their XML exports.  Graphical model interchange is difficult enough in XPDL, where the graphics come pre-attached to their semantic elements. A few BPMN 1.x tool vendors – ITP Commerce, Fujitsu, Global360, eClarus, TIBCO, BizAGI, and Lombardi – have achieved some level of BPMN interoperability using XPDL 2.1, but it requires tweaks to the XPDL using XSLT, the standard language for XML transformation. It would be extremely difficult to create those tweaks with DI – and they no doubt will still be needed with BPMN 2.0 – since tools that create, execute, and debug XSLT all need a proper schema. OMG needs to try again on the DI part.

It is no great feat to turn DI into a proper BPMN-specific schema. I did it myself (BpmnDi.xsd) in a few hours. I also created an XSLT that maps XPDL 2.1 to BPMN 2.0, using BpmnDi as the graphics model. If your BPMN tool outputs XPDL 2.1, you can try it out on your own models. [So far only the XPDL “standard”-level conformance is supported.]  If you are interested in interoperability between BPMN tools, please make your sentiments known to OMG.  These implementation “details” are what the FTF phase is all about.

Similar Resources

Understanding the Difference Between a Certificate and Certification

Understanding the Difference Between a Certificate and Certification

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

As professionals seek to advance their careers or pivot to new fields, understanding the variety of learning and credentialing options is essential. At BPMInstitute.org, we often encounter students wondering whether they should pursue a certificate or certification in Business Process Management (BPM). This article is designed to clarify the differences, highlight the benefits of each, and guide prospective students in making the best decision for their career goals.

Enhancing Your Team’s BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise

Enhancing Your Team’s BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Enhancing Your Team's BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise In today’s dynamic business environment, managing and improving business processes is critical for any organization aiming to maintain a competitive edge. Many companies consider handling Business...

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+ Introduction In the evolving landscape of Business Process Management (BPM), the introduction of Shared Data Model Notation (SDMN) marks a significant advancement. As businesses increasingly seek to...

Featured Certificate: BPM Specialist

Everyone starts here.

You're looking for a way to improve your process improvement skills, but you're not sure where to start.

Earning your Business Process Management Specialist (BPMS) Certificate will give you the competitive advantage you need in today's world. Our courses help you deliver faster and makes projects easier.

Your skills will include building hierarchical process models, using tools to analyze and assess process performance, defining critical process metrics, using best practice principles to redesign processes, developing process improvement project plans, building a center of excellence, and establishing process governance.

The BPMS Certificate is the perfect way to show employers that you are serious about business process management. With in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management, you'll be able to take your business career to the next level.

Learn more about the BPM Specialist Certificate

Courses

  •  

 

Certificates

  • Business Process Management Specialist
  • Earning your Business Process Management Specialist (BPMS) Certificate will provide you with a distinct competitive advantage in today’s rapidly evolving business landscape. With in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management, you’ll be able to take your business career to the next level.
  • BPM Professional Certificate
    Business Process Management Professional
  • Earning your Business Process Management Professional (BPMP) Certificate will elevate your expertise and professional standing in the field of business process management. Our BPMP Certificate is a tangible symbol of your achievement, demonstrating your in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management.

Certification

BPM Certification

  • Make the most of your hard-earned skills. Earn the respect of your peers and superiors with Business Process Management Certification from the industry's top BPM educational organization.

Courses

 

Certificates

  • Operational Excellence Specialist
  • Earning your Operational Excellence Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in driving organizational excellence and achieving sustainable improvements in performance.
 

 

OpEx Professional Certificate

  • Operational Excellence Professional
  • Earn your Operational Excellence Professional Certificate and gain a competitive edge in driving organizational excellence and achieving sustainable improvements in performance.

Courses

Certificate
  •  

  • Agile BPM Specialist
  • Earn your Agile BPM Specialist Certificate and gain a competitive edge in driving business process management (BPM) with agile methodologies. You’ll gain a strong understanding of how to apply agile principles and concepts to business process management initiatives.  
 

Business Architecture

 

Certificates

  • Business Architecture Specialist
  • The Business Architecture Specialist (BAIS) Certificate is proof that you’ve begun your business architecture journey by committing to the industry’s most meaningful and credible business architecture training program.

  • Business Architecture Professional
  • When you earn your Business Architecture Professional (BAIP) Certificate, you will be able to design and implement a governance structure for your organization, develop and optimize business processes, and manage business information effectively.

BA CertificationCertification

  • Make the most of your hard-earned skills. Earn the respect of your peers and superiors with Business Architecture Certification from the industry's top BPM educational organization.

Courses

 

Certificates

  • Digital Transformation Specialist
  • Earning your Digital Transformation Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in today’s rapidly evolving business landscape. 
 

 

  • Digital Transformation Professional
  • The Digital Transformation Professional Certificate is the first program in the industry to cover all the key pillars of Digital Transformation holistically with practical recommendations and exercises.

Courses

Certificate

  • Agile Business Analysis Specialist
  • Earning your Agile Business Analysis Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in the world of agile software development.

Courses

Certificate
  • DAS Certificate
  • Decision Automation Specialist
  • Earning your Decision Automation Certificate will empower you to excel in the dynamic field of automated decision-making, where data-driven insights are pivotal to driving business innovation and efficiency.