BPMS Watch: Can Business Analysts Model Exception Handling?

Author(s)

Business Relationship Manager - Product Lifecycle Management, Chevron Corporation

It’s conventional wisdom in business that 80% of the problems are caused by 20% of the work – the “exceptions.” In BPM, therefore, you’d think that exception handling would be a critical focus of process modeling and analysis. In most cases you’d be wrong.

Certainly the designers of the Business Process Modeling Notation (BPMN) standard at BPMI (now part of OMG) had exception handling in mind from the start. BPMN introduces to process modeling the notion of intermediate events. It’s a godawful name but an absolutely essential concept for making exception handling visible in the process diagram and understandable to business people. In fact, events are the key difference between BPMN and traditional flowcharting.

In BPMN, intermediate events are drawn as circles with a double border, with a symbol inside denoting the type of event: receipt of an external signal (message), a timeout, a system fault, etc. When drawn attached to the border of a process activity or subprocess, the semantics of BPMN say that the activity or subprocess is interrupted immediately, and the process continues along the flow path leading out from the intermediate event. That path is called “exception flow.” If the event never occurs, the activity or subprocess completes normally and processing continues along the flow path leading out from it. That path is called “normal flow.” Is that hard to understand? No, I didn’t think so.

You’d be surprised, then, to know that a number of modeling tools offered by BPMS vendors that advertise themselves as BPMN-compliant don’t support intermediate events. What those vendors usually say is that the concept is too technical for business analysts to understand. What they really mean, in most cases, is that their process engine – the thing that “executes” the model to automate and monitor the process flow – can’t handle them. The modeling tool’s simulation engine has no idea what to do with them, either. So they’re just left out of the tool. Shame on OMG for allowing this pseudo-BPMN to proliferate as it has.

The traditional alternative to modeling exception handling explicitly in the process diagram is to do it in code, toss it over the wall to IT. Once in a while this might be necessary, but as a general principle it’s just plain wrong. By removing exception handling from the process model and burying it in implementation code, you’ve not only lost visibility into what’s going on, you’ve lost the ability to use it in simulation analysis, you’ve lost agility, reuse, shared best practices, etc. All of those assume exception handling is in the process model.

In addition to intermediate events, BPMN adds another important notion to the process modeler’s vocabulary: business transactions. A transaction here means a collection of activities that must be performed “atomically” – all must complete successfully – or else the system must be “rolled back” to its initial state, as if none of them had ever occurred. Unlike classic transaction protocols like two-phase commit, where the resource performing each part of the transaction must be “locked” until the transaction either commits or rolls back, business transactions are by definition “long-running” – seconds to days – too long to lock the resources, which also means you can’t really roll back to the initial state.

Instead, if any activity in the business transaction cannot complete successfully, any already completed activity must be undone by a compensating activity and any uncompleted activities in the transaction are abandoned. Undoing a debit, for example, might be issuing a credit for the same amount. It’s not a rollback as if neither had happened – both the charge and the credit show up on your Visa bill – but it has equivalent business effect.

Here’s a scenario. You’re booking a trip to Europe online, air and hotel. Neither the airline nor the hotel can guarantee either price or availability until you actually book specific dates with a credit card. Yes, it’s a nasty world we live in. But if you can’t match the dates of both hotel and air, you’re reservation isn’t much good. So consider them part of a single business transaction. Let’s even imagine that you first select your preferred complete itinerary (hotel and air) and then instruct the travel site to book it. Let’s assume the travel site models this as a BPMN business transaction, first booking the hotel (no cancellation fee) and then the air (no avoiding the cancellation fee). The BPMN might look like this:

Figure 1: BPMN

The subprocess enclosing Book Hotel and Book Air acts as a business transaction. If the hotel is unavailable, the subprocess completes without booking the air. But if the hotel is available, it is booked with a deposit on the credit card. If the air is not available, the subprocess completes with a compensation end event – a call to completed activities to execute their defined compensation activity. For the Book Hotel activity, the compensation activity Cancel Hotel (with compensating credit for the deposit) is identified by its link to the compensation intermediate event on the boundary of Book Hotel. The explanation may be long-winded, but the diagram is concise and explicit.

This is about business semantics, not programming. Business analysts can understand intermediate events, exception flows, and compensation. The problem to date has been a lack of quality training on BPMN supported by a clear methodology for translating process knowledge into diagram correctly. The current state of market education on BPMN is really quite appalling. That’s why I’m putting together my own training materials on Process Modeling with BPMN. Exception handling is too important to be tossed over the wall to the programmers. Real training and a methodology can give process analysts the tools they need to define how exceptions should be handled in their critical business processes.

Similar Resources

Enhancing Your Team’s BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise

Enhancing Your Team’s BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Enhancing Your Team's BPM Capabilities: The Value of External Expertise In today’s dynamic business environment, managing and improving business processes is critical for any organization aiming to maintain a competitive edge. Many companies consider handling Business...

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Exploring Shared Data Model and Notation (SDMN) and Its Role in BPM+ Introduction In the evolving landscape of Business Process Management (BPM), the introduction of Shared Data Model Notation (SDMN) marks a significant advancement. As businesses increasingly seek to...

Article: Embracing the Future: Low-Code and No-Code Platforms in BPM+

Article: Embracing the Future: Low-Code and No-Code Platforms in BPM+

Author(s):

Editor & Founder, BPMInstitute.org, BAInstitute.org and DBIZInstitute.org

Article: Embracing the Future: Low-Code and No-Code Platforms in BPM+ Introduction In the realm of business process management (BPM), low-code and no-code platforms have emerged as transformative tools, reshaping how organizations develop applications and manage...

Featured Certificate: BPM Specialist

Everyone starts here.

You're looking for a way to improve your process improvement skills, but you're not sure where to start.

Earning your Business Process Management Specialist (BPMS) Certificate will give you the competitive advantage you need in today's world. Our courses help you deliver faster and makes projects easier.

Your skills will include building hierarchical process models, using tools to analyze and assess process performance, defining critical process metrics, using best practice principles to redesign processes, developing process improvement project plans, building a center of excellence, and establishing process governance.

The BPMS Certificate is the perfect way to show employers that you are serious about business process management. With in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management, you'll be able to take your business career to the next level.

Learn more about the BPM Specialist Certificate

Courses

  •  

 

Certificates

  • Business Process Management Specialist
  • Earning your Business Process Management Specialist (BPMS) Certificate will provide you with a distinct competitive advantage in today’s rapidly evolving business landscape. With in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management, you’ll be able to take your business career to the next level.
  • BPM Professional Certificate
    Business Process Management Professional
  • Earning your Business Process Management Professional (BPMP) Certificate will elevate your expertise and professional standing in the field of business process management. Our BPMP Certificate is a tangible symbol of your achievement, demonstrating your in-depth knowledge of process improvement and management.

Certification

BPM Certification

  • Make the most of your hard-earned skills. Earn the respect of your peers and superiors with Business Process Management Certification from the industry's top BPM educational organization.

Courses

 

Certificates

  • Operational Excellence Specialist
  • Earning your Operational Excellence Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in driving organizational excellence and achieving sustainable improvements in performance.
 

 

OpEx Professional Certificate

  • Operational Excellence Professional
  • Earn your Operational Excellence Professional Certificate and gain a competitive edge in driving organizational excellence and achieving sustainable improvements in performance.

Courses

Certificate
  •  

  • Agile BPM Specialist
  • Earn your Agile BPM Specialist Certificate and gain a competitive edge in driving business process management (BPM) with agile methodologies. You’ll gain a strong understanding of how to apply agile principles and concepts to business process management initiatives.  
 

Business Architecture

 

Certificates

  • Business Architecture Specialist
  • The Business Architecture Specialist (BAIS) Certificate is proof that you’ve begun your business architecture journey by committing to the industry’s most meaningful and credible business architecture training program.

  • Business Architecture Professional
  • When you earn your Business Architecture Professional (BAIP) Certificate, you will be able to design and implement a governance structure for your organization, develop and optimize business processes, and manage business information effectively.

BA CertificationCertification

  • Make the most of your hard-earned skills. Earn the respect of your peers and superiors with Business Architecture Certification from the industry's top BPM educational organization.

Courses

 

Certificates

  • Digital Transformation Specialist
  • Earning your Digital Transformation Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in today’s rapidly evolving business landscape. 
 

 

  • Digital Transformation Professional
  • The Digital Transformation Professional Certificate is the first program in the industry to cover all the key pillars of Digital Transformation holistically with practical recommendations and exercises.

Courses

Certificate

  • Agile Business Analysis Specialist
  • Earning your Agile Business Analysis Specialist Certificate will provide you with a distinct advantage in the world of agile software development.

Courses

Certificate
  • DAS Certificate
  • Decision Automation Specialist
  • Earning your Decision Automation Certificate will empower you to excel in the dynamic field of automated decision-making, where data-driven insights are pivotal to driving business innovation and efficiency.